Upon the Edge of a Swordfish
November 28th, 2008
Do you ever ask a waiter for a suggestion at a restaurant, and then completely ignore him and order something different? Its almost as if you were looking for justification for one of your previous choices–its not that you really cared what his opinion was, you just wanted to have someone to blame if what you picked was bad. But this waiter failed to provide you with such a scapegoat. This waiter caught you off-guard. He suggested something from page 5, not even off the chef’s specials list, and now, rather than a “Very good choice, sir”, you’re left with far more fundamental questions than you bargained for. A question of moral hazard–is he just recommending what’s about to be thrown away? A question of decision making–you wouldn’t stop by the side of the road to ask him for directions; why should you listen to him for something that you will shortly consume? A question of stereotyping–Is he recommending something (spicy/bland) just because you’re (South Asian/white)?
Such were the questions running through my mind as, deciding between the crab and the halibut, the waiter declared, unprompted and with confidence, “May I just remind you, sir, that we are in the height of swordfish season, and it is better than I have ever seen.” What? That wasn’t one of the choices. What game are you trying to play? The crab cakes are a signature dish. And they wouldn’t put that on just anything, right? So should I trust the chef, or should I trust you? Narrowing it to two was hard enough, and now you have to go and do that.
I alternated my concentration between the expression on the waiter’s face and the description of the house-special crab cakes, hoping that either one would reveal to me a sign of the course on which I should proceed, but neither the description nor his gaze changed, until I paused, and a small smile crept on the waiter’s face. He knew that the battle was over, and that he had won. He probably knew from the beginning. My main course would now be both literally and figuratively in his hands. What happened next? Stay tuned for Episode 2: “Something Swordfishy in the City of Cambridge” or “The Swordfish is Mightier.”






